Matlacha Isles, Cape Coral FL - Homes for Sale

11 homes for sale in Matlacha Isles with an average listing price of $650,154 and an average size of 1,744 sqft.

12277 Boat Shell DR Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12277 Boat Shell DR, Matlacha Isles

$949,999 Single Family
MLS®: 225084805 • Days Listed: 34
3 beds • 3 baths • 2802 sqFt
$ reduced from $999,999, 2026-01-29

12234 Boat Shell DR Cape Coral FL 33991

12234 Boat Shell DR, Cape Coral

$874,900 Single Family
MLS®: 2025025787 • Days Listed: 45
3 beds • 2 baths • 1960 sqFt

12304 Boat Shell DR Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12304 Boat Shell DR, Matlacha Isles

$869,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2025020052 • Days Listed: 105
3 beds • 3 baths • 2340 sqFt
$ reduced from $875,000, 2026-03-02

12235 Boat Shell DR Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12235 Boat Shell DR, Matlacha Isles

$775,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2026001561 • Days Listed: 23
3 beds • 2 baths • 1405 sqFt

12196 Matlacha BLVD Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12196 Matlacha BLVD, Matlacha Isles

$610,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2026002365 • Days Listed: 68
3 beds • 2 baths • 1935 sqFt
$ reduced from $625,000, 2026-03-03

12230 Matlacha BLVD Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12230 Matlacha BLVD, Matlacha Isles

$599,900 Single Family
MLS®: 224060123 • Days Listed: 603
3 beds • 2 baths • 1830 sqFt
$ reduced from $606,250, 2026-03-16

12055 Matlacha BLVD Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12055 Matlacha BLVD, Matlacha Isles

$536,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2026001958 • Days Listed: 13
3 beds • 2 baths • 1506 sqFt

12206 Boat Shell DR Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12206 Boat Shell DR, Matlacha Isles

$499,999 Single Family
MLS®: 225047183 • Days Listed: 187
2 beds • 1 baths

12101 Moon Shell DR Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12101 Moon Shell DR, Matlacha Isles

$499,900
MLS®: 224086941 • Days Listed: 330

17638 Corallina DR Matlacha Isles FL 33991

17638 Corallina DR, Matlacha Isles

$487,500 Single Family
MLS®: 226002429 • Days Listed: 49
3 beds • 3 baths • 1496 sqFt
$ reduced from $500,000, 2026-03-06

12262 Boat Shell DR Matlacha Isles FL 33991

12262 Boat Shell DR, Matlacha Isles

$449,500 Single Family
MLS®: 2026003144 • Days Listed: 55
2 beds • 2 baths • 1244 sqFt
$ reduced from $489,000, 2026-03-13