Herons Landings I, Sanibel FL - Homes for Sale

4 homes for sale in Herons Landings I with an average listing price of $1,496,250 and an average size of 2,818 sqft.

5435 Osprey CT Sanibel FL 33957

5435 Osprey CT, Sanibel

$1,899,999 Single Family
MLS®: 225061045 • Days Listed: 258
4 beds • 4 baths • 3266 sqFt
$ reduced from $2,000,000, 2026-03-16

5438 Shearwater DR Sanibel FL 33957

5438 Shearwater DR, Sanibel

$1,765,000 Single Family
MLS®: 225060952 • Days Listed: 262
3 beds • 4 baths • 2460 sqFt
$ reduced from $1,795,000, 2026-01-31

1987 My Tern CT Sanibel FL 33957

1987 My Tern CT, Sanibel

$1,225,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2025020448 • Days Listed: 118
3 beds • 3 baths • 3306 sqFt
$ reduced from $1,375,000, 2026-03-16

5422 Osprey CT Sanibel FL 33957

5422 Osprey CT, Sanibel

$1,095,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2026006531 • Days Listed: Today
3 beds • 3 baths • 2240 sqFt

5398 Osprey CT Sanibel FL 33957

5398 Osprey CT, Sanibel

$295,000 Lot / Land
MLS®: 225061299 • Days Listed: 240
$ reduced from $319,000, 2025-12-03