Captains Bay South, Fort Myers Beach FL - Homes for Sale

7 homes for sale in Captains Bay South with an average listing price of $474,100 and an average size of 1,091 sqft.

22748 Island Pines WAY 503 Fort Myers Beach FL 33931

22748 Island Pines WAY 503, Fort Myers Beach

$525,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2026007390 • Days Listed: 12
2 beds • 2 baths • 1059 sqFt

22736 Island Pines WAY 502 Fort Myers Beach FL 33931

22736 Island Pines WAY 502, Fort Myers Beach

$519,900 Single Family
MLS®: 2025021865 • Days Listed: 89
3 beds • 2 baths • 1239 sqFt
$ reduced from $549,000, 2026-02-20

22748 Island Pines WAY 401 Fort Myers Beach FL 33931

22748 Island Pines WAY 401, Fort Myers Beach

$475,000 Single Family
MLS®: 2025005566 • Days Listed: 176
2 beds • 2 baths • 1059 sqFt
$ reduced from $489,500, 2025-11-19

22712 Island Pines WAY 501 Fort Myers Beach FL 33931

22712 Island Pines WAY 501, Fort Myers Beach

$459,999 Single Family
MLS®: 225082499 • Days Listed: 71
2 beds • 2 baths • 1073 sqFt
$ reduced from $499,000, 2026-01-12

22748 Island Pines WAY 401 Fort Myers Beach FL 33931

22748 Island Pines WAY 401, Fort Myers Beach

$449,900 Single Family
MLS®: 2026007196 • Days Listed: 26
2 beds • 2 baths • 1059 sqFt

22736 Island Pines WAY S 201 Fort Myers Beach FL 33931

22736 Island Pines WAY S 201, Fort Myers Beach

$449,000 Single Family
MLS®: 225076921 • Days Listed: 132
2 beds • 2 baths • 1073 sqFt
$ reduced from $464,999, 2026-01-14

22724 Island Pines WAY 101 Fort Myers Beach FL 33931

22724 Island Pines WAY 101, Fort Myers Beach

$439,900 Single Family
MLS®: 225007503 • Days Listed: 376
2 beds • 2 baths • 1073 sqFt
$ reduced from $449,900, 2026-02-19